Most business rates challenges argue that the valuation was wrong from the start. A material change of circumstances - usually shortened to MCC - is different. It says the valuation was fine once, but something has changed since, and the rateable value should change with it.
Roadworks outside a shop for most of a year. A neighbouring building demolished and rebuilt next to your office. An access road to an industrial estate closed. Part of your own building taken out of use. These are the situations MCC was made for.
What counts
The change has to be physical, and it has to affect what a tenant would pay to occupy the property. The common ones are:
- Changes to the property itself. Part demolished, extended, split, merged or converted to a different use.
- Changes in the locality. A new road layout, a closed access, the loss of nearby parking, a major development next door.
- Temporary disruption. Long-running roadworks, scaffolding across a shopfront, construction noise and dust from a neighbouring site. These can justify a reduction for as long as the disruption lasts.
What does not count
- The economy. Rents falling, a quieter high street, a recession. The valuation is fixed at a set date for the whole list, and general market changes after that date are not grounds for a reduction.
- Your business. Trading performance is not the test for most property. A struggling business in an unchanged building has no MCC case.
Why the detail matters
MCC cases are won or lost on evidence and on how the ground is put. The change has to be shown to be physical, to have happened on a particular date, and to have affected rental value - not just trade. A case put on the wrong basis is rejected without the Valuation Office looking at the merits, and because you get one Challenge per Check, that can be the end of it.
The evidence that helps is practical: dated photographs, council notices for roadworks or road closures, planning documents for the development next door, and a clear account of how the property has actually been affected - access blocked, frontage hidden, part of the building unusable.
Timing
Act while it is happening. A reduction can usually take effect from the date of the change, but how far back it reaches depends on the rules of the list and on when the case is made - and evidence is far easier to gather during the disruption than a year after it has gone. Where the change is temporary, the assessment goes back up when it ends, so the earlier the case is made, the more of the period it covers.
Is it worth it?
Often, yes, particularly for retail and leisure property where the frontage and access are the whole point of the location. It is also one of the areas of rating where the ratepayer usually knows something has happened before anyone else does.
If something has changed around your property, send us the address and a line on what has happened. The initial review is free, and we will tell you plainly whether there is a case and how strong it is.

Chartered Surveyor. Twelve years in business rates at Altus Group (now Ryan), four of them as a Director, and more than fifteen years of rating work across the South of England and London. RICS-regulated firm no. 897221.
Not sure whether your assessment is right?
Send us the rates bill or just the property address. We will look at the published assessment and tell you honestly whether there is a case worth pursuing. There is no charge for that first view.
Request a free rates reviewThis article is general information about how business rates work in England, written for ratepayers. It is not advice on any particular property, and the rules change. If a decision turns on it, take advice on the facts of your own case.